In 2004, the project was brought to a halt when James Hetfield checked into a California rehab facility, where he would spend the next six months, overcoming a drug addiction. Since 'overcoming a drug addiction' is a participle phrase modifying 'he', I though the comma was correct. But it just doesnt' sound right. Please only respond if you are qualified to answer. Thanks.
Words & Wordplay - 8 Answers
Random Answers, Critics, Comments, Opinions :
1 :
The comma after "month" is correct. The phrase "where he would spend the next six months" is a prepositional phrase and those should always be set of by commas at the beginning and at the end.
2 :
There is no need for the comma after "months". "Where he would spend the next six months" isn't a prepositional phrase. A prepositional phrase is something like "in the bedroom" and begins with a preposition. Where is a relative adverb, but it is correct to have a comma in front of where.
3 :
Seriously, u dont need the comma. Look at it this way, when u read a paragraph or sentence and see a comma, what it pretty much means is to take a pause. try it. re-read it and ull see what i mean. or read other sentences and see how u read with the comma in place.
4 :
The comma after "months" should not be there, it creates confusion. If the comma is there, then "overcoming a drug addiction" applies to the clause before the first comma, which makes no sense and is grammatically incorrect. The gerund phrase "overcoming a drug addiction" applies to the past imperfect defined by something he was doing for the past six months, so no comma.
5 :
I don't think it sounds right, either. The phrase regards James Hetfield, who checked into a California rehab facility, where he would spend the next six months overcoming a drug addiction. The word "where" makes the following words part of a prepositional phrase, in which 'he' is the noun or subject, 'overcoming' is the verb, and 'a drug addiction' the object. The whole thing is a prepositional phrase and should not be broken up by a comma. Your instincts are right.
6 :
In 2004 the project was brought to a halt, when James Hetfield checked into a California rehab facility, where he would spend the next six months overcoming a drug addiction.
7 :
No comma after 'months'. .
8 :
No; it does not belong there.
Read more discussion
- Can my previous employer tell prospective employer...
- what to do about a girlfriend with a drug problem
- Separated because of drug abuse..what do we do? ca...
- My drug addiction help
No comments:
Post a Comment